π° Entry-Level (~$350K β $700K)
Charming island-style living without the luxury price tag:
-
Anglers Cove β Marco Island
Affordable waterfront condos with boat docks and walking distance to shops and restaurants. Prices start in the $300Ksβ$500Ks. -
Useppa Island Cottages β North of Captiva
Quieter private island community accessible only by boat; small homes and cottages occasionally hit the market in the $500Kβ$700K range. -
Mainland-Adjacent Island Homes β St. James City (Pine Island)
Island homes with water access and small-town charm; many under $600K, especially in off-water spots.
πΌ Mid-Range (~$700K β $1.5M)
Detached homes and waterfront condos with island aesthetics, water access, and strong community vibes:
-
South Seas Resort Condos β Captiva Island
Resort-like island living with full amenities and marina access. Condos in the $800Kβ$1.2M range. -
Hideaway Beach Club β Marco Island
Gated beachfront community with a golf course and relaxed island vibe. Villas and condos range from $900Kβ$1.5M. -
Matlacha Cottages β Matlacha Island
Artsy, quirky island homes often with canal frontage and tropical color. Homes range $700Kβ$1.1M, depending on water access.
β¨ Luxury ($1.5M+)
Private islands, luxury beachfront homes, or ultra-premium island condos:
-
Captiva Island Estates β Captiva
Secluded luxury estates with direct Gulf access, private beaches, and lush tropical settings. Most listings $3Mβ$12M+. -
Key Marco β Marco Island
Exclusive gated island with custom homes, elevated views, and protected lands. Homes range from $2Mβ$6M+. -
Sanibel Island Gulf-Front Homes β Sanibel
Luxury beachfront or canal-front homes in Sanibelβs top-tier neighborhoods. Prices start around $2M and can exceed $10M+.