$1,049,000
4 Bed Pool Home for Sale in Gumbo Limbo
9439 Cotten Court, Sanibel, FL, 33957
About this home
This impeccably located Old Florida-style lake-front 4 Bedroom home offers an ideal blend of privacy and convenience. Nestled on the east end of the island, it boasts 180+/- feet of serene lake frontage on an oversized lot with mature native vegetation and lush landscaping, providing stunning lake views. The location ensures easy access on and off the island, perfect for year-round residents. This well-maintained home, fully updated and ready to be your forever home, features a grand entrance with a winding drive, a grand staircase, and a private elevator. The raised caged pool, recently resurfaced with new pavers and a new pool heater (2023), is a standout feature, complemented by large porches, abundant deck space, and a new metal roof (2024). Inside, the main living level boasts high ceilings, a cupola, and a fireplace in the great room. The master suite offers his and hers baths, while two guest suites each have private baths. Additional spaces include a den with a half bath, a huge loft area, a formal dining room, and a kitchen with high-end Bosch and Monogram appliances. Modern comforts are ensured with a new mini split AC unit, updated AC ductwork, a new dishwasher, and two new water heaters. The lower level includes three large garage bays and ample storage and recreational space. This home combines timeless style with contemporary updates in a secluded, yet accessible, setting.
Property details
- Type
- SingleFamilyResidence
- Year built
- 1984
- Interior
- 3,150 sqft
- Lot size
- 34,848 sqft
- Acreage
- 0.80 acres
- Garage
- 3 car
- Days on market
- 454
- Total association fees
- $250/yr (~$21/mo)
- CDD
- None
- Est. taxes (1.4%)
- $14,686/yr
- Flood zone (area est.)
- Not available
- Storm protection
- None listed
- Exposure
- East
- Waterfront
- Yes
- Gulf access
- No
- Gulf access type
- N/A
- Pool
- Yes
- Spa
- No
- Natural gas
- No
- Water
- Public
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- New construction
- No
- Pets
- Yes
- County
- Lee
Total association fees sums the core association dues the MLS feed provides (HOA, condo/master association, and land lease), normalized to a yearly figure. These are separate from and additional to specialty charges, mandatory club or food-and-beverage minimums, special assessments, and rec-lease fees, which the IDX feed does not carry. Always confirm the full fee schedule with the HOA or listing agent.
Maintenance included in the fee
What the association dues cover, per the MLS. Confirm the full schedule with the HOA.
We rate a home against recently SOLD homes within ~1 mile that match on size, beds/baths, and age. This home doesn't have enough close comparables in the last 12 months for a reliable read, ask Rick for a personalized CMA.
Seeing several homes? Build a tour and we'll route it for you.
Your notes on this home
Keep private notes on this home, what you love, what to ask about, saved to your account and shared with your agent.
Recently sold nearby
Closed comparable sales within ~1 mile in the last 12 months, similar price, size, beds/baths, and age.
| Address | Sold | Sold price | Beds/Baths | Sq ft | $/sqft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1406 Causey Court | Apr 2026 | $795,000 | 3/2 | 3,095 | $257 |
| 220 Daniel Drive | Aug 2026 | $840,000 | 3/3 | 3,009 | $279 |
| Average | 2 comps | $817,500 | $268 |
Market trends, Sanibel
Median of closed MLS sales each month over the available window. Months with too few sales are omitted; the range extends automatically as more sales close.
Live area medians from the MLS · see all listings. Indicative, not an appraisal.
Price & status history
Down $590,000 (37.4%) from the original list price.
| Nov 14, 2025 | Sold | $989,000 |
| Sep 26, 2025 | Price reducedfrom $999,000 | $1,049,000 |
| Sep 16, 2025 | Back on market | |
| Jul 7, 2024 | Listed | $1,579,000 |
The good, the trade-offs & the location
- Private pool
- Waterfront
- 3-car garage
- Built 1984 — pre-2002 construction may carry older wind codes and higher insurance
Straight-line distances to major SWFL amenities, approximate; actual drive times vary.
Nearby schools
Get more information on their programs, scores, and extracurriculars on each school's page · browse the full schools directory.
Similar homes nearby
$1,199,000
MLS# 20260019591401 Sand Castle Road, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$1,100,000
MLS# 20260229709007 Mockingbird Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$899,000
MLS# 20250144502420 Cherimoya Lane, St James City, FL, 33956
$995,000
MLS# 20250209013284 Twin Lakes Lane, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$849,000
MLS# 20260271122579 Eighth Avenue, St James City, FL, 33956
$1,090,000
MLS# 20250161102999 Twin Ponds Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
Listing information is provided in part by the Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service (MLS) through its Broker Reciprocity / Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program. Properties displayed may be listed by brokerages other than SWFL Relocation Team. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS or this brokerage and should be independently verified. Fees, flood zones, taxes, square footage, and school assignments are estimates from the feed and must be confirmed. © 2026 SWFL Relocation Team. All rights reserved.