What are home prices like in Eagle Cay?

Eagle Cay is in the mid price tier, typically Typically $450K – $900K. List prices vary by size, age, condition, and inventory. Search current listings at /search.

What FEMA flood zone is Eagle Cay in?

Eagle Cay is mapped primarily in FEMA Zone AE, High risk · 1% annual chance · BFE established. Parcels can differ; Rick verifies the exact zone for any address.

What schools are near Eagle Cay?

Per current MLS listings, Eagle Cay is served by Tommie Barfield Elementary School (grade A), Marco Island Charter Middle (grade A), Marco Island Academy (grade A). Collier County uses zoning/school-choice that can vary by address; confirm before you offer.

What does it cost to own a home in Eagle Cay?

For a $650,000 home in Eagle Cay: ~$8,450/yr property tax, $7,800-$14,300/yr insurance incl. flood, and $300-900/mo HOA. See the cost cheatsheet at /swfl-relocation-cost-cheatsheet.

What amenities does Eagle Cay offer?

Eagle Cay features Waterfront, Gulf Access, Boating. Compare similar communities at /communities.

Marco Island, FL · Waterfront & Boating Communities

Eagle Cay

Eagle Cay is a residential community in Marco Island, Collier County, Southwest Florida.

Waterfront & Boating CommunitiescondoMid · $450K – $900KFEMA Zone AE

Market Snapshot

Eagle Cay market data

Live from the MLS · updated continuously. See all 3 listings →

Active Listings

for sale now

Median List Price

$620,000

active inventory

Median $/Sq Ft

$466

list price ÷ sqft

Avg Days on Market

197

days listed

Price Range

$554,000-$625,000

low to high

Sold (90 days)

$570,500

2 closed · median

Homes Built

1980-1988

Typical Home

2 bed · 1,330 sq ft

Waterfront

100% of homes

Median sold price · Eagle Cay

$570,500last 3 monthsnot enough sold data to compare

Figures reflect current active listings (and recent closed sales where available) tagged to Eagle Cay. Medians are indicative, not an appraisal, ask Rick for a comparative market analysis on a specific home.

On the Map

Where Eagle Cay sits

Loading map…

Available Now

Homes for sale in Eagle Cay(3)

Newest listings first.

See all 3 homes →View on map →

Swipe to see more →

Recently Sold

Recent sales in Eagle Cay

Home	Bd / Ba	Sq Ft	Sold	Sold Price
901 Collier Court 5-903, Marco Island	2 / 2	1,125	Sep 2026	$626,000
897 Collier Court 4-705, Marco Island	2 / 2	1,125	Jun 2026	$515,000
889 COLLIER Court 2-203, Marco Island	2 / 2	1,125	Apr 2026	$600,000
901 Collier Court 905, Marco Island	2 / 2	1,125	Oct 2025	$700,000

Closed sales from the last 12 months. Ask Rick for a full comparable-sales report on any home you're considering.

At a Glance

Eagle Cay at a glance

Price Range

Mid

Typically $450K – $900K

Flood Zone

Zone AE

High risk · 1% annual chance · BFE established

high-confidence estimate, verify by address

Community Type

condo

Region

Marco Island

Amenities & Lifestyle

What you get living in Eagle Cay

WaterfrontGulf AccessBoating

Drive Times

Location & access

🏖️ Nearest Beach8 min
✈️ RSW Airport65 min
🏙️ Downtown Fort Myers39 min
🏥 Nearest Hospital41 min
🛣️ I-75 Access45 min

Cost of Ownership

Estimated yearly costs for a mid-tier home

Florida estimates based on a $650,000 home in Eagle Cay. Actual numbers vary, book a Strategy Session for a live, parcel-specific quote.

Property Tax

$8,450

~$704/mo · Collier County millage ~1.3%

Insurance (incl. flood)

$7,800, $14,300

Flood + wind in high-risk zone

HOA Estimate

$300, $900/mo

Condo association range

Estimates only. Florida Homestead Exemption (when you qualify) can knock $750-1,500 off the annual tax bill.

⚠️ Flood Zone Accuracy Note

Eagle Cay is mapped primarily in Zone AE

All sample points within Eagle Cay returned Zone AE. Individual parcels may differ, flood zones are assigned per parcel by FEMA, not per community.

Before making an offer, always verify the exact flood zone for the specific property address:

🔍 Verify on FEMA Map Service Center →Ask Rick for the Exact Zone →

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer · sampled at 5 points per community · confidence: high

Schools

Schools serving Eagle Cay

Elementary

Tommie Barfield Elementary School

FL DOE score 70/100 · 2024-25 grade

Middle

Marco Island Charter Middle

FL DOE score 67/100 · 2024-25 grade

High

Marco Island Academy

FL DOE score 69/100 · 2024-25 grade

Assigned schools based on current MLS listings in Eagle Cay, with Florida Department of Education 2024-25 grades. Collier County uses zoning and school-choice options that can change by address and year, so confirm the exact assignment with the district before you offer.

Compare

Ready to Look Closer?

Get live numbers for Eagle Cay

HOA dues, current listings, recent sales, builder incentives, all change weekly. Book a free Strategy Session and I'll pull a live snapshot for Eagle Cay tailored to your timeline and budget.

Ask About Eagle Cay →Find Communities Like This (90-sec quiz)

Good Questions

Eagle Cay, frequently asked questions

What are home prices like in Eagle Cay?: Eagle Cay is in the mid price tier, typically Typically $450K – $900K. List prices vary by size, age, condition, and current inventory; search current listings or ask Rick for live comps.
What FEMA flood zone is Eagle Cay in?: Eagle Cay is mapped primarily in FEMA Zone AE, High risk · 1% annual chance · BFE established. Individual parcels can differ; Rick verifies the exact zone for any address.
What schools are near Eagle Cay?: Per current MLS listings, Eagle Cay is served by Tommie Barfield Elementary School (grade A), Marco Island Charter Middle (grade A), Marco Island Academy (grade A). Collier County uses zoning and school-choice options that can vary by address, so confirm the exact assignment before you offer.
What does it cost to own a home in Eagle Cay?: For a $650,000 home, estimate roughly $8,450/yr property tax, $7,800-$14,300/yr insurance (incl. flood), and $300-$900/mo HOA. Full breakdown in the SWFL cost cheatsheet.
What amenities does Eagle Cay offer?: Eagle Cay features Waterfront, Gulf Access, Boating. Compare similar communities on the interactive map.