$500,000
5 Bed 3.5 Bath Waterfront SingleFamilyResidence for Sale in CATALINA ISLES, FL
8591 Sumner Avenue, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
About this home
Welcome to Catalina Isles! This stunning 2-story single-family home with a beautiful water view offers 5 bedrooms, 3.5 baths, and over 3,100 sq ft of living space. Offering formal living/dining, plus family room, you will fall in love with the open feeling! Stainless appliances, dark wood cabinets, plenty of counter space and cabinetry, with a walk-in pantry. NEW A/C IN 2025! Amazing Lake views from the breakfast and family room, plus a screened in lanai. Plenty of room for a pool! An upstairs loft area ideal space for a home office. Master suite entertains a large sitting area, dual primary bathrooms with walk through shower and two walk in closets. Half bath conveniently located on the first floor. Catalina Isles amenities include; community pool, spa, playground, fitness center and BBQ grills. Conveniently located near HealthPark and Golisano Children's Hospital, and just minutes from Fort Myers Beach and Sanibel. This spacious home is the perfect blend of luxury and comfort. This one won’t last!
Property details
- Type
- SingleFamilyResidence
- Year built
- 2009
- Interior
- 3,142 sqft
- Lot size
- 6,490.44 sqft
- Acreage
- 0.15 acres
- Garage
- 2 car
- Days on market
- 26
- Total association fees
- $4,020/yr (~$335/mo)
- CDD
- None
- Est. taxes (1.4%)
- $7,000/yr
- Flood zone (area est.)
- Yes · High risk (AE)
- Storm protection
- Shutters
- Exposure
- North
- Waterfront
- Yes
- Gulf access
- No
- Gulf access type
- N/A
- Pool
- No
- Spa
- No
- Natural gas
- No
- Water
- Public
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- New construction
- No
- Pets
- Call, Conditional
- County
- Lee
Total association fees sums the core association dues the MLS feed provides (HOA, condo/master association, and land lease), normalized to a yearly figure. These are separate from and additional to specialty charges — mandatory club or food-and-beverage minimums, special assessments, and rec-lease fees — which the IDX feed does not carry. Always confirm the full fee schedule with the HOA or listing agent.
Maintenance included in the fee
What the association dues cover, per the MLS. Confirm the full schedule with the HOA.
Amenities
Flood risk shown is an area-level estimate and can differ from a specific unit's actual FEMA designation (which varies by structure and elevation). Look up this address on the FEMA Flood Map and verify with a licensed insurance agent before relying on it.
Based on the $/sqft of 3 comparable homes sold nearby in the last 12 months. Indicative, not an appraisal.
Seeing several homes? Build a tour and we'll route it for you.
Your notes on this home
Keep private notes on this home — what you love, what to ask about — saved to your account and shared with your agent.
Recently sold nearby
Closed comparable sales within ~1 mile in the last 12 months — similar price, size, beds/baths, and age.
| Address | Sold | Sold price | Beds/Baths | Sq ft | $/sqft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 17051 TREMONT Street | Nov 2025 | $490,000 | 5/4 | 3,200 | $153 |
| 17088 Wrigley Circle | Jul 2026 | $620,000 | 4/3 | 3,093 | $200 |
| 8850 Pigeon Key | Dec 2025 | $587,500 | 5/4 | 3,017 | $195 |
| Average | 3 comps | $565,833 | $183 |
Market trends — Fort Myers
Median of closed MLS sales each month over the available window. Months with too few sales are omitted; the range extends automatically as more sales close.
Live area medians from the MLS · see all listings. Indicative, not an appraisal.
Price & status history
Down $50,000 (10%) from the original list price.
| Dec 18, 2025 | Sold | $450,000 |
| Oct 25, 2025 | Listed | $500,000 |
The good, the trade-offs & the location
- Built 2009 — post-2002 Florida wind codes (typically lower insurance)
- Waterfront
- Storm protection: Shutters
- 2-car garage
- In a higher-risk flood zone (AE) — flood insurance likely required
Straight-line distances to major SWFL amenities — approximate; actual drive times vary.
Nearby schools
Get more information on their programs, scores, and extracurriculars on each school's page · browse the full schools directory.
Similar homes nearby
$434,900
MLS# 202602354517026 Tremont Street, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
$415,000
MLS# 202603138716845 Colony Lakes Boulevard, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
$474,900
MLS# 20260213727226 Hendry Creek Drive, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
$425,500
MLS# 202600173111800 Bayport Lane 2601, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
$410,000
MLS# 202601507216580 Crownsbury Way 202, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
$429,900
MLS# 202600113511099 Sea Tropic Lane, Fort Myers, FL, 33908
Listing information is provided in part by the Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service (MLS) through its Broker Reciprocity / Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program. Properties displayed may be listed by brokerages other than SWFL Relocation Team. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS or this brokerage and should be independently verified. Fees, flood zones, taxes, square footage, and school assignments are estimates from the feed and must be confirmed. © 2026 SWFL Relocation Team. All rights reserved.