This Week's Best Under-Market Real Estate Deals in Southwest Florida | Fort Myers, Naples & SWFL
This week Im bringing you 9 comp-verified homes for sale in Southwest Florida that are priced _far_ below what comparable properties have recently sold for in their respective neighborhoods. Whether your looking for a permanent home, a solid investment property, or just a seasonal getaway, these 9 homes represent some of the very best bargains currently out on the market
#1 Best Deal on the Market: 16737 Pheasant Court, Fort Myers
$209,900 · 3bd/2ba · 1,855 sqft · ~20% below recent sold comps
Here is a 3 bed room home in Fort Myers - it has almost 1900 square feet of living space - and the asking price is 20% under whats been selling for in the area recently. Here you get loads of house for your money - excellent square footage per dollar - and the fact its on Pheasant Court puts you close enough to all the Fort Myers has to offer without the price tag of living in some of the more up-market areas thats right on your doorstep
#2 Best Deal on the Market: 4531 Bay Beach Lane 134, Fort Myers Beach
$299,900 · 2bd/2ba · 1,225 sqft · ~20% below recent sold comps
At 20% below comparable sales , this 2 bedroom Fort Myers Beach condo offers the ultimate beach lifestyle at a price that's ridiculously underpriced for a place so close to the sand. The Bay Beach Lane spot puts you literally just steps away from the Gulf of Mexico and with prices so low they're hard to ignore - that's why this place works just as well for investors looking to cash in on rental income as it does for those after a low-key beach retreat of their own.
#3 Best Deal on the Market: 4263 Bay Beach Lane 111, Fort Myers Beach
$289,900 · 2bd/2ba · 1,175 sqft · ~20% below recent sold comps
Another Bay Beach Lane opportunity - this two bed / two bath unit is priced a full 20% under recent comparable sales - and its one of the most accessible entry points to owning a piece of paradise at Fort Myers Beach. With a comfortable just under 1,200 square feet, its a super efficient layout that really maximises livability without breaking the bank.
Gulf Access: 4591 Bay Beach Lane 294, Fort Myers Beach
$305,000 · 2bd/2ba · 1,226 sqft · ~19% below recent sold comps
Gulf access in this price point is about as scarce as hens teeth these days ,and this Fort Myers Beach condo is sitting a full 19% below comparable properties that have closed in recent times. Boaters and water enthusiasts will be REALLY stoked to have the access right there at their fingertips , and the Bay Beach Lane complex is a real winner - offering the kind of resort-style amenities that will genuinely make owning here a real pleasure.
Waterfront: 401 Arbor Lake Drive 4-101, Naples
$215,000 · 2bd/2ba · 1,493 sqft · ~18% below recent sold comps
This Naples waterfront condo at Arbor Lake comes in at almost 1,500 square feet, & is a whopping 18% below the current prices you'd expect to pay for a place in this neighbourhood. Buyers get 2 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and great water views - all for a price that lets you live the Naples lifestyle with out the typical hefty price tag that usually comes with it in a Naples zip code.
Pool Home: 80 Delbrook Way, Marco Island
$1,375,000 · 4bd/2ba · 2,723 sqft · ~13% below recent sold comps
Priced 13% below comps, this 4-bedroom Marco Island pool home delivers over 2,700 square feet of living space with outdoor entertaining built in. The combination of island location, pool amenity, and below-market pricing makes this a standout for families or anyone wanting the full Marco Island experience.
55+ / Active Adult: 104 Fleur De Lis Lane, Naples
$199,800 · 3bd/2ba · 1,580 sqft · ~13% below recent sold comps
This 3 bedroom home in a Naples 55 plus community, is priced a full 13% under recent sales figures giving active adult buyers a fabulous combination of space , location and sheer bang for their buck . At a respectable price point of under $200k , it stands as one of the more accessible entry points into Naples' age qualified living scene, with a solid 1580 square feet of living space that's perfect for putting down roots .
Amenity-Rich: 135 Quails Nest Road 4, Naples
$189,990 · 2bd/2ba · 1,542 sqft · ~14% below recent sold comps
Sitting below comparable sales by 14%, this 2-bedroom Naples condo in the desirable Quails Nest complex offers a pretty sweet deal on a resort style lifestyle. The sub $190K price tag is unusually low for Naples and when you factor in the great community and all the included amenities, it adds up to a pretty unbeatable value for the dollar - no extra cash outlay required.
Investor (rental): 550 Teryl Road 2302, Naples
$219,000 · 2bd/2ba · 1,403 sqft · ~12% below recent sold comps
This 2 bedroom Naples condo is coming in at 12% below recent comparable sales and has some really attractive fundamentals for investors. It's a great deal in a super desirable part of Naples and the rental market is looking pretty favorable too. The address on Teryl Road is a real winner - its close to employment hubs and shopping, which really helps keep tenants in the property and ensures the occupancy rates stay strong.
Every 1 of these verified comps - i personally go over them to verify the numbers are on the money & that the value is genuine. If any of these homes tick your boxes or you'd like me to run a custom search with your specific needs in mind , give me a shout any time for further assistance.
Browse every Southwest Florida listing →
Deals are measured against the median of recent nearby sold comparables (within 1 mile, similar size, age, and beds/baths, closed in the last 6 months). Prices and availability change fast; contact Rick to confirm.