$1,499,000
3 Bed 3.5 Bath Pool SingleFamilyResidence for Sale in BUTTERKNIFE, FL
2179 Starfish Lane, Sanibel, FL, 33957
About this home
MOTIVATED SELLER. Welcome to Sanibel Island! This home and gated community offer an exceptional blend of natural beauty, lush, tropical grounds, and a community that supports an active lifestyle. Sanibel is renowned for its stunning beaches, rich wildlife, and an array of outdoor activities that cater to all tastes and preferences. Whether it's a peaceful stroll along the shore, visiting the local boutiques or an adventurous day exploring the island’s many trails, Sanibel is a paradise waiting to be discovered. The Butterknife neighborhood is a gated haven, characterized by exclusivity and charm. Only 34 distinguished homes grace this community, fostering a close-knit environment that is both inviting and secure. Here, life unfolds with access to Sanibel's iconic 25-mile shared-use path, making it easy for residents to enjoy cycling, jogging, and embracing the local outdoors. Nearby, an assortment of dining and shopping opportunities enrich everyday living. As for the home itself, prepare to be enamored by its large yet intimate living spaces. Designed for both comfort and elegance, each of the spacious bedrooms includes an ensuite bathroom, offering a personal retreat for everyone. The inviting deck and patio lead to a large pool and together set the stage for both lively gatherings and tranquil afternoons under the sun. Future-friendly features such as tall ceilings and an interior elevator ensure the home is suited for all stages of life, pallowing residents to embrace aging in place with sophistication. Practical elements like a garage large enough for cars and work benches plus hurricane protection add extra layers of convenience to this exceptional residence.
Property details
- Type
- SingleFamilyResidence
- Year built
- 2007
- Interior
- 2,730 sqft
- Lot size
- 31,624.56 sqft
- Acreage
- 0.73 acres
- Garage
- 4 car
- Days on market
- 173
- Total association fees
- $2,562/yr (~$214/mo)
- CDD
- None
- Est. taxes (1.4%)
- $20,986/yr
- Flood zone (area est.)
- Not available
- Storm protection
- Impact Windows/Doors
- Exposure
- South
- Waterfront
- No
- Gulf access
- No
- Gulf access type
- N/A
- Pool
- Yes
- Spa
- Yes
- Natural gas
- No
- Water
- Public
- Sewer
- Public Sewer
- New construction
- No
- Pets
- Yes
- County
- Lee
Total association fees sums the core association dues the MLS feed provides (HOA, condo/master association, and land lease), normalized to a yearly figure. These are separate from and additional to specialty charges — mandatory club or food-and-beverage minimums, special assessments, and rec-lease fees — which the IDX feed does not carry. Always confirm the full fee schedule with the HOA or listing agent.
Maintenance included in the fee
What the association dues cover, per the MLS. Confirm the full schedule with the HOA.
Amenities
Based on the $/sqft of 4 comparable homes sold nearby in the last 12 months. Indicative, not an appraisal.
Seeing several homes? Build a tour and we'll route it for you.
Your notes on this home
Keep private notes on this home — what you love, what to ask about — saved to your account and shared with your agent.
Recently sold nearby
Closed comparable sales within ~1 mile in the last 12 months — similar price, size, beds/baths, and age.
| Address | Sold | Sold price | Beds/Baths | Sq ft | $/sqft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2312 Starfish Lane | May 2026 | $1,800,000 | 4/3 | 2,833 | $635 |
| 811 Birdie View Point | Mar 2026 | $1,400,000 | 3/2 | 2,544 | $550 |
| 788 Birdie View Point | Mar 2026 | $1,600,000 | 3/3 | 2,909 | $550 |
| 3351 Barra Circle | May 2026 | $1,250,000 | 3/2 | 2,539 | $492 |
| Average | 4 comps | $1,512,500 | $557 |
Market trends — Sanibel
Median of closed MLS sales each month over the available window. Months with too few sales are omitted; the range extends automatically as more sales close.
Live area medians from the MLS · see all listings. Indicative, not an appraisal.
Price & status history
Down $180,000 (10.9%) from the original list price.
| Jun 25, 2026 | Sold | $1,470,000 |
| Feb 13, 2026 | Price reducedfrom $1,599,000 | $1,499,000 |
| Nov 5, 2025 | Listed | $1,650,000 |
The good, the trade-offs & the location
- Built 2007 — post-2002 Florida wind codes (typically lower insurance)
- Private pool
- Storm protection: Impact Windows/Doors
- 4-car garage
Straight-line distances to major SWFL amenities — approximate; actual drive times vary.
Nearby schools
Get more information on their programs, scores, and extracurriculars on each school's page · browse the full schools directory.
Similar homes nearby
$1,375,000
MLS# 20260188431251 Par View Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$1,295,000
MLS# 2025025058400 Rabbit Road, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$1,200,000
MLS# 20250032311286 Par View Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$1,299,000
MLS# 20260122771238 Par View Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$1,695,000
MLS# 20250264201233 Middle Gulf Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
$1,365,000
MLS# 20260092821360 Jamaica Drive, Sanibel, FL, 33957
Listing information is provided in part by the Florida Gulf Coast Multiple Listing Service (MLS) through its Broker Reciprocity / Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program. Properties displayed may be listed by brokerages other than SWFL Relocation Team. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS or this brokerage and should be independently verified. Fees, flood zones, taxes, square footage, and school assignments are estimates from the feed and must be confirmed. © 2026 SWFL Relocation Team. All rights reserved.